Investigator appointed to lead independent review of Carr case

An investigator has been appointed to lead an independent review of the Byron Carr murder investigation.

The Honorable Duncan R. Beveridge has been appointed as an investigator under the Police Act. 

"The resulting report and recommendations from this review will be delivered to me and subsequently be made public. It is important to be clear that the review is not to determine liability. It will focus on ensuring police and prosecutorial practices follow best practices for major crime investigations.”

- Justice and Public Safety Minister Bloyce Thompson 

Justice Beveridge is a retired justice of the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal. Prior to his appointment to the bench, he practiced law as a crown prosecutor and defence lawyer. In addition, he has experience in carrying out independent reviews, as part of the Westray prosecution in Nova Scotia and then as senior counsel for the review of the Government of Nova Scotia’s response to reports of institutional abuse.

“I have committed to Justice Beveridge that his review will be completely independent, and he will have the resources he considers necessary to fulfill his mandate,” said Minister Thompson. “That said, if he concludes additional powers are warranted, he can submit an interim report to me with recommendations to that end.”

The review will begin January 4, 2027 and is expected to take several months to a year.

 

Media contact:
Katie Cudmore 
Department of Justice and Public Safety 
[email protected]

 

Backgrounder:

Terms of reference for Justice Beveridge’s investigation

Purpose 

The purpose of this appointment is to:  

  • review the circumstances and handling of the Byron Carr homicide investigation conducted by the Charlottetown Police Service, including file management and oversight, evidence and asset management, inter-agency coordination, as well as interaction and consultation with Crown services;  
  • review the operation and administration of the Charlottetown Police Service as a police department in relation to modern policing standards and expectations for Prince Edward Island for major case file investigations; and 
  • make findings regarding the Byron Carr homicide investigation conducted by the Charlottetown Police Service, as well as standards and expectations for major case file police investigations in Prince Edward Island. 

Responsibilities  

The investigation undertaken as a result of the appointment shall be conducted pursuant to section 4 of the Police Act to:  

  • review investigation management, oversight, inter-agency coordination, and interactions with Crown services, regarding the Byron Carr homicide investigation by Charlottetown Police Services, including relevant factors, decisions, policies, practices or biases that may have affected service delivery, investigative outcomes, or public confidence; and 
  • review modern policing standards and expectations for Prince Edward Island regarding major case file investigations, including minimum standards, policies and procedures for 
  • case management investigative practices;  
  • the creation, maintenance, retention, accessibility, and disclosure of investigative files and records;  
  • the collection, handling, storage, tracking, disclosure, retention, and disposition of evidence; 
  • evidence continuity and chain of custody;  
  • exhibit, property, and evidence management systems and controls; 
  • inter-agency coordination and Crown services interaction; 
  • organizational governance; 
  • supervision, accountability, leadership and oversight; and 
  • training and development. 

Report 

Upon completion of the investigation the investigator shall, pursuant to section 4(4) of the Act, prepare and submit a written report to the Minister, which shall include the investigator’s findings. 

The investigator’s report will be released to the public subject only to legal and privacy considerations. 

Published date: